Authors, peer reviewers, and readers: What is expected from each player in collaborative publishing?

Fernando Fernandez-Llimos; Pharmacy Practice 2020 peer reviewers; Jackie Roseleur

doi:10.18549/PharmPract.2021.1.2284

Authors, peer reviewers, and readers: What is expected from each player in collaborative publishing?

Fernando Fernandez-Llimos, Pharmacy Practice 2020 peer reviewers, Jackie Roseleur

College of Medicine and Public Health

Research output: Contribution to journal › Editorial

11 Citations (Scopus)

3 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Scholarly publishing is in a crisis, with the many stakeholders complaining about different aspects of the system. Authors want fast publication times, high visibility and publications in high-impact journals. Readers want freely accessible, high-quality articles. Peer reviewers want recognition for the work they perform to ensure the quality of the published articles. However, authors, peer reviewers, and readers are three different roles played by the same group of individuals, the users of the scholarly publishing system—and this system could work based on a collaborative publishing principle where “nobody pays, and nobody gets paid”.

Original language	English
Article number	2284
Pages (from-to)	1-6
Number of pages	6
Journal	Pharmacy Practice
Volume	19
Issue number	1
DOIs	https://doi.org/10.18549/PharmPract.2021.1.2284
Publication status	Published - Jan 2021

Keywords

Cooperative Behavior
Open Access Publishing
Peer Review, Research
Periodicals as Topic

Access to Document

10.18549/PharmPract.2021.1.2284Licence: CC BY-NC-ND

Published versionFinal published version, 654 KBLicence: CC BY-NC-ND

Cite this

@article{798aaac9896741c1a0f74d6deed47540,

title = "Authors, peer reviewers, and readers: What is expected from each player in collaborative publishing?",

abstract = "Scholarly publishing is in a crisis, with the many stakeholders complaining about different aspects of the system. Authors want fast publication times, high visibility and publications in high-impact journals. Readers want freely accessible, high-quality articles. Peer reviewers want recognition for the work they perform to ensure the quality of the published articles. However, authors, peer reviewers, and readers are three different roles played by the same group of individuals, the users of the scholarly publishing system—and this system could work based on a collaborative publishing principle where “nobody pays, and nobody gets paid”.",

keywords = "Cooperative Behavior, Open Access Publishing, Peer Review, Research, Periodicals as Topic",

author = "Fernando Fernandez-Llimos and {Pharmacy Practice 2020 peer reviewers} and Edita Alili-Idrizi and Amin, {Mohamed E.} and Zubin Austin and Billups, {Sarah J.} and Cavaco, {Afonso M.} and Collins, {Jack C.} and Eserian, {Jaqueline K.} and Andi Hermansyah and Janke, {Kristin K.} and Jarrett, {Jennie B.} and Pascale Salameh and Ieva Stupans and Abdel-Qader, {Derar H.} and Dania Abunaser and Rasaq Adisa and Wuraola Akande-Sholabi and Ahmad Al-Azayzih and Selamawit Alemayehu and Alzubaidi, {Hamzah T.} and Johanna Aponte-Gonz{\'a}lez and Arnall, {Justin R.} and Beata Bajorek and David Balayssac and Bardet, {Jean Didier} and Marie Barnard and Susanne Barnett and Basheti, {Iman A.} and Arcelio Benetoli and Bennett, {Shelby A.} and Emily Black and Bloom, {Timothy J.} and Bonetti, {Aline F.} and Borba, {Helena H.} and Daniel Bradley and Bradshaw, {Pamela J.} and Cecilia Brata and Jovana Brkic and David Brumbaugh and Guido, {Paulo Caceres} and Cathal Cadogan and Jeffrey Cain and Ron Carico and Carvajal, {Manuel J.} and Margarida Castel-Branco and Damien Cateau and Jagjot Chahal and Vincent Chan and Charrois, {Theresa L.} and Ejaz Cheema and Chen, {Timothy F.} and Chung, {Eun K.} and Cicali, {Emily J.} and Peter Clap and Kevin Clayton and Clifton, {Peter M.} and Cohen, {Lisa B.} and Kevin Cowart and Crumby, {Ashley S.} and Cunha-Filho, {Marc{\'i}lio S.} and Dalia Dawoud and Thomas Delate and Rhian Deslandes and Sarah Dineen-Griffin and Mark Dunnenberger and Iffat Elbarazi and Elbur, {Abubaker I.} and Abigail Elmes and Farris, {Karen B.} and Tanja Fens and Cathy Ficzere and Fidler, {Brooke D.} and Fink, {Joseph L.} and Fink, {Rhianna M.} and Paul Forsyth and Jaheeda Gangannagaripalli and Garcia, {Beate H.} and Cardenas, {Victoria Garcia} and Marise Gauci and Gharaibeh, {Shadi F.} and Smith, {Kathrine Gibson} and Gochenauer, {Alexandria E.} and Nina Griese-Mammen and Guerreiro, {Mara P.} and Kyrillos Guirguis and Trine Gulholm and Genevieve Hale and Souheil Hallit and Tora Hammar and Hussein Haruna and Hassali, {Mohamed A.} and Herdeiro, {Maria T.} and Hermes-Desantis, {Evelyn R.} and Hincapie, {Ana L.} and Samantha Hollingworth and Rabia Hussain and Ibrahim, {Osama H.} and Irwin, {Adriane N.} and Katia Iskandar and Jackson, {Idongesit L.} and Arianit Jakupi and Susanne Kaae and Sporrong, {Sofia K{\"a}lvemark} and Katoue, {Maram G.} and Margaret Kay and Viviane Khalil and Eli{\v s}ka Kolmanov{\'a} and Koster, {Andries S.} and Milena Kova{\v c}evi{\'c} and Yoshiki Kusama and Torre, {Giuseppe La} and Marta Lavrador and Lawson, {Katherine A.} and Luana Lenzi and Leticia Leonart and Lewis, {Nancy J.} and Chelsey Llayton and Loo, {Jason S.} and L{\'o}pez, {Jos{\'e} Juli{\'a}n} and Karen Luetsch and Macdonald, {Elyse A.} and Makowsky, {Mark J.} and Abdulaziz Malik and Andrea Manfrin and Efi Mantzouranie and Martin, {Craig A.} and Mason, {Nancy A.} and Tressa McMorris and Medina, {Melissa S.} and Melo, {Angelita C.} and Mendo{\c c}a, {Simone A.} and Meredith, {Ashley H.} and Markus Messereli and Jason Min and Mira, {Jos{\'e} J.} and Moczygemba, {Leticia R.} and Rebekah Moles and Jean Moon and Moore, {Gina D.} and Mona Mostaghim and Fiona Needleman and Rosemary Newham and Marcel Nogueira and Pauline Norris and Marina Odalovi{\'c} and Olavarr{\'i}a, {Ver{\'o}nica V.} and Stefano Omboni and Osemene, {Kanayo P.} and Park, {Ha Eun Leena} and Gregory Peterson and Philbrick, {Ann M.} and Pires, {Carla M.} and Patricia Quintana-Barcena and Andrew Radley and Radwan, {Rotana M.} and Reis, {Adriano M.} and Olaf Rose and Jackie Roseleur and Inajara Rotta and Daniel Sabater-Hernandez and Saha, {Sajal K.} and Fahad Saleem and John Saunders and Nathalie Sayegh and Schellhase, {Ellen M.} and Scott, {David M.} and Robert Seabury and Andrew Stafford and Derek Stewart and Bruce Sunderland and Judith Strawbridge and Damian {\'S}wieczkowski and Meng-Wong Taing and Tonin, {Fernanda S.} and Torres, {Neusa F.} and Triboletti, {Jessica S.} and Pasitpon Vatcharavongvan and Veronica Vernon and Daisy Volmer and Onanong Waleekhachonloet and Wilby, {Kyle J.} and Astrid Wiens and Witry, {Matthew J.} and Witt, {Daniel M.} and Payom Wongpoowarak and Yaacoub, {Sally G.} and Ismaeel Yunusa and Romana Zelk{\'o} and Kristin Zimmerman",

year = "2021",

month = jan,

doi = "10.18549/PharmPract.2021.1.2284",

language = "English",

volume = "19",

pages = "1--6",

journal = "Pharmacy Practice",

issn = "1885-642X",

publisher = "Centro de Investigaciones y Publicaciones Farmaceuticas",

number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Authors, peer reviewers, and readers

T2 - What is expected from each player in collaborative publishing?

AU - Fernandez-Llimos, Fernando

AU - Pharmacy Practice 2020 peer reviewers

AU - Alili-Idrizi, Edita

AU - Amin, Mohamed E.

AU - Austin, Zubin

AU - Billups, Sarah J.

AU - Cavaco, Afonso M.

AU - Collins, Jack C.

AU - Eserian, Jaqueline K.

AU - Hermansyah, Andi

AU - Janke, Kristin K.

AU - Jarrett, Jennie B.

AU - Salameh, Pascale

AU - Stupans, Ieva

AU - Abdel-Qader, Derar H.

AU - Abunaser, Dania

AU - Adisa, Rasaq

AU - Akande-Sholabi, Wuraola

AU - Al-Azayzih, Ahmad

AU - Alemayehu, Selamawit

AU - Alzubaidi, Hamzah T.

AU - Aponte-González, Johanna

AU - Arnall, Justin R.

AU - Bajorek, Beata

AU - Balayssac, David

AU - Bardet, Jean Didier

AU - Barnard, Marie

AU - Barnett, Susanne

AU - Basheti, Iman A.

AU - Benetoli, Arcelio

AU - Bennett, Shelby A.

AU - Black, Emily

AU - Bloom, Timothy J.

AU - Bonetti, Aline F.

AU - Borba, Helena H.

AU - Bradley, Daniel

AU - Bradshaw, Pamela J.

AU - Brata, Cecilia

AU - Brkic, Jovana

AU - Brumbaugh, David

AU - Guido, Paulo Caceres

AU - Cadogan, Cathal

AU - Cain, Jeffrey

AU - Carico, Ron

AU - Carvajal, Manuel J.

AU - Castel-Branco, Margarida

AU - Cateau, Damien

AU - Chahal, Jagjot

AU - Chan, Vincent

AU - Charrois, Theresa L.

AU - Cheema, Ejaz

AU - Chen, Timothy F.

AU - Chung, Eun K.

AU - Cicali, Emily J.

AU - Clap, Peter

AU - Clayton, Kevin

AU - Clifton, Peter M.

AU - Cohen, Lisa B.

AU - Cowart, Kevin

AU - Crumby, Ashley S.

AU - Cunha-Filho, Marcílio S.

AU - Dawoud, Dalia

AU - Delate, Thomas

AU - Deslandes, Rhian

AU - Dineen-Griffin, Sarah

AU - Dunnenberger, Mark

AU - Elbarazi, Iffat

AU - Elbur, Abubaker I.

AU - Elmes, Abigail

AU - Farris, Karen B.

AU - Fens, Tanja

AU - Ficzere, Cathy

AU - Fidler, Brooke D.

AU - Fink, Joseph L.

AU - Fink, Rhianna M.

AU - Forsyth, Paul

AU - Gangannagaripalli, Jaheeda

AU - Garcia, Beate H.

AU - Cardenas, Victoria Garcia

AU - Gauci, Marise

AU - Gharaibeh, Shadi F.

AU - Smith, Kathrine Gibson

AU - Gochenauer, Alexandria E.

AU - Griese-Mammen, Nina

AU - Guerreiro, Mara P.

AU - Guirguis, Kyrillos

AU - Gulholm, Trine

AU - Hale, Genevieve

AU - Hallit, Souheil

AU - Hammar, Tora

AU - Haruna, Hussein

AU - Hassali, Mohamed A.

AU - Herdeiro, Maria T.

AU - Hermes-Desantis, Evelyn R.

AU - Hincapie, Ana L.

AU - Hollingworth, Samantha

AU - Hussain, Rabia

AU - Ibrahim, Osama H.

AU - Irwin, Adriane N.

AU - Iskandar, Katia

AU - Jackson, Idongesit L.

AU - Jakupi, Arianit

AU - Kaae, Susanne

AU - Sporrong, Sofia Kälvemark

AU - Katoue, Maram G.

AU - Kay, Margaret

AU - Khalil, Viviane

AU - Kolmanová, Eliška

AU - Koster, Andries S.

AU - Kovačević, Milena

AU - Kusama, Yoshiki

AU - Torre, Giuseppe La

AU - Lavrador, Marta

AU - Lawson, Katherine A.

AU - Lenzi, Luana

AU - Leonart, Leticia

AU - Lewis, Nancy J.

AU - Llayton, Chelsey

AU - Loo, Jason S.

AU - López, José Julián

AU - Luetsch, Karen

AU - Macdonald, Elyse A.

AU - Makowsky, Mark J.

AU - Malik, Abdulaziz

AU - Manfrin, Andrea

AU - Mantzouranie, Efi

AU - Martin, Craig A.

AU - Mason, Nancy A.

AU - McMorris, Tressa

AU - Medina, Melissa S.

AU - Melo, Angelita C.

AU - Mendoça, Simone A.

AU - Meredith, Ashley H.

AU - Messereli, Markus

AU - Min, Jason

AU - Mira, José J.

AU - Moczygemba, Leticia R.

AU - Moles, Rebekah

AU - Moon, Jean

AU - Moore, Gina D.

AU - Mostaghim, Mona

AU - Needleman, Fiona

AU - Newham, Rosemary

AU - Nogueira, Marcel

AU - Norris, Pauline

AU - Odalović, Marina

AU - Olavarría, Verónica V.

AU - Omboni, Stefano

AU - Osemene, Kanayo P.

AU - Park, Ha Eun Leena

AU - Peterson, Gregory

AU - Philbrick, Ann M.

AU - Pires, Carla M.

AU - Quintana-Barcena, Patricia

AU - Radley, Andrew

AU - Radwan, Rotana M.

AU - Reis, Adriano M.

AU - Rose, Olaf

AU - Roseleur, Jackie

AU - Rotta, Inajara

AU - Sabater-Hernandez, Daniel

AU - Saha, Sajal K.

AU - Saleem, Fahad

AU - Saunders, John

AU - Sayegh, Nathalie

AU - Schellhase, Ellen M.

AU - Scott, David M.

AU - Seabury, Robert

AU - Stafford, Andrew

AU - Stewart, Derek

AU - Sunderland, Bruce

AU - Strawbridge, Judith

AU - Świeczkowski, Damian

AU - Taing, Meng-Wong

AU - Tonin, Fernanda S.

AU - Torres, Neusa F.

AU - Triboletti, Jessica S.

AU - Vatcharavongvan, Pasitpon

AU - Vernon, Veronica

AU - Volmer, Daisy

AU - Waleekhachonloet, Onanong

AU - Wilby, Kyle J.

AU - Wiens, Astrid

AU - Witry, Matthew J.

AU - Witt, Daniel M.

AU - Wongpoowarak, Payom

AU - Yaacoub, Sally G.

AU - Yunusa, Ismaeel

AU - Zelkó, Romana

AU - Zimmerman, Kristin

PY - 2021/1

Y1 - 2021/1

N2 - Scholarly publishing is in a crisis, with the many stakeholders complaining about different aspects of the system. Authors want fast publication times, high visibility and publications in high-impact journals. Readers want freely accessible, high-quality articles. Peer reviewers want recognition for the work they perform to ensure the quality of the published articles. However, authors, peer reviewers, and readers are three different roles played by the same group of individuals, the users of the scholarly publishing system—and this system could work based on a collaborative publishing principle where “nobody pays, and nobody gets paid”.

AB - Scholarly publishing is in a crisis, with the many stakeholders complaining about different aspects of the system. Authors want fast publication times, high visibility and publications in high-impact journals. Readers want freely accessible, high-quality articles. Peer reviewers want recognition for the work they perform to ensure the quality of the published articles. However, authors, peer reviewers, and readers are three different roles played by the same group of individuals, the users of the scholarly publishing system—and this system could work based on a collaborative publishing principle where “nobody pays, and nobody gets paid”.

KW - Cooperative Behavior

KW - Open Access Publishing

KW - Peer Review, Research

KW - Periodicals as Topic

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85099717445&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.18549/PharmPract.2021.1.2284

DO - 10.18549/PharmPract.2021.1.2284

M3 - Editorial

AN - SCOPUS:85099717445

SN - 1885-642X

VL - 19

SP - 1

EP - 6

JO - Pharmacy Practice

JF - Pharmacy Practice

IS - 1

M1 - 2284

ER -

Authors, peer reviewers, and readers: What is expected from each player in collaborative publishing?

Abstract

Keywords

Access to Document

Other files and links

Fingerprint

Cite this