TY - JOUR

T1 - How Accurate Are Approximate Methods for Evaluating Partition Functions for Hindered Internal Rotations?

AU - Lin, Ching Yeh

AU - Izgorodina, Ekaterina I.

AU - Coote, Michelle L.

PY - 2008/3/1

Y1 - 2008/3/1

N2 - The accuracy of several low-cost methods (harmonic oscillator approximation, CT-Cω, SR-TDPPI-HS, and TDPPI-HS) for calculating one-dimensional hindered rotor (1D-HR) partition functions is assessed for a test set of 644 rotations in 104 organic molecules, using full torsional eigenvalue summation (TES) as a benchmark. For methods requiring full rotational potentials, the effect of the resolution at which the rotational potential was calculated was also assessed. Although lower-cost methods such as Pitzer's Tables are appropriate when potentials can be adequately described by simple cosine curves, these were found to show large errors (as much as 3 orders of magnitude) for non-cosine curve potentials. In those cases, it is found that the TDPPI-HS method in conjunction with a potential compiled at a resolution of 60° offers the best compromise between accuracy and computational expense. It can reproduce the benchmark values of the partition functions for an individual mode to within a factor of 2; its average error is just of a factor of 1.08. The corresponding error in the overall internal rotational partition functions of the molecules studied is less than a factor of 4 in all cases. Excellent cost-effective performance is also offered by CT-Cω, which requires only the geometries, energies, and frequencies of the distinguishable minima in the potential. With this method the geometric mean error in individual partition functions is 1.14, the maximum error is a modest 2.98 and the resulting error in the total 1D-HR partition function of a molecule is less than a factor of 5 in all cases.

AB - The accuracy of several low-cost methods (harmonic oscillator approximation, CT-Cω, SR-TDPPI-HS, and TDPPI-HS) for calculating one-dimensional hindered rotor (1D-HR) partition functions is assessed for a test set of 644 rotations in 104 organic molecules, using full torsional eigenvalue summation (TES) as a benchmark. For methods requiring full rotational potentials, the effect of the resolution at which the rotational potential was calculated was also assessed. Although lower-cost methods such as Pitzer's Tables are appropriate when potentials can be adequately described by simple cosine curves, these were found to show large errors (as much as 3 orders of magnitude) for non-cosine curve potentials. In those cases, it is found that the TDPPI-HS method in conjunction with a potential compiled at a resolution of 60° offers the best compromise between accuracy and computational expense. It can reproduce the benchmark values of the partition functions for an individual mode to within a factor of 2; its average error is just of a factor of 1.08. The corresponding error in the overall internal rotational partition functions of the molecules studied is less than a factor of 4 in all cases. Excellent cost-effective performance is also offered by CT-Cω, which requires only the geometries, energies, and frequencies of the distinguishable minima in the potential. With this method the geometric mean error in individual partition functions is 1.14, the maximum error is a modest 2.98 and the resulting error in the total 1D-HR partition function of a molecule is less than a factor of 5 in all cases.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=41549091976&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1021/jp710341h

DO - 10.1021/jp710341h

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:41549091976

VL - 112

SP - 1956

EP - 1964

JO - Journal of Physical Chemistry A

JF - Journal of Physical Chemistry A

SN - 1089-5639

IS - 9

ER -