Reply to: Shark mortality cannot be assessed by fishery overlap alone

Nuno Queiroz; Nicolas E. Humphries; Ana Couto; Marisa Vedor; Ivo da Costa; Ana M.M. Sequeira; Gonzalo Mucientes; António M. Santos; Francisco J. Abascal; Debra L. Abercrombie; Katya Abrantes; David Acuña-Marrero; André S. Afonso; Pedro Afonso; Darrell Anders; Gonzalo Araujo; Randall Arauz; Pascal Bach; Adam Barnett; Diego Bernal; Michael L. Berumen; Sandra Bessudo Lion; Natalia P.A. Bezerra; Antonin V. Blaison; Barbara A. Block; Mark E. Bond; Ramon Bonfil; Russell W. Bradford; Camrin D. Braun; Edward J. Brooks; Annabelle Brooks; Judith Brown; Barry D. Bruce; Michael E. Byrne; Steven E. Campana; Aaron B. Carlisle; Demian D. Chapman; Taylor K. Chapple; John Chisholm; Christopher R. Clarke; Eric G. Clua; Jesse E.M. Cochran; Estelle C. Crochelet; Laurent Dagorn; Ryan Daly; Daniel Devia Cortés; Thomas K. Doyle; Michael Drew; Clinton A.J. Duffy; Thor Erikson; Eduardo Espinoza; Luciana C. Ferreira; Francesco Ferretti; John D. Filmalter; G. Chris Fischer; Richard Fitzpatrick; Jorge Fontes; Fabien Forget; Mark Fowler; Malcolm P. Francis; Austin J. Gallagher; Enrico Gennari; Simon D. Goldsworthy; Matthew J. Gollock; Jonathan R. Green; Johan A. Gustafson; Tristan L. Guttridge; Hector M. Guzman; Neil Hammerschlag; Luke Harman; Fábio H.V. Hazin; Matthew Heard; Alex R. Hearn; John C. Holdsworth; Bonnie J. Holmes; Lucy A. Howey; Mauricio Hoyos; Robert E. Hueter; Nigel E. Hussey; Charlie Huveneers; Dylan T. Irion; David M.P. Jacoby; Oliver J.D. Jewell; Ryan Johnson; Lance K.B. Jordan; Warren Joyce; Clare A. Keating Daly; James T. Ketchum; A. Peter Klimley; Alison A. Kock; Pieter Koen; Felipe Ladino; Fernanda O. Lana; James S.E. Lea; Fiona Llewellyn; Warrick S. Lyon; Anna MacDonnell; Bruno C.L. Macena; Heather Marshall; Jaime D. McAllister; Michael A. Meÿer; John J. Morris; Emily R. Nelson; Yannis P. Papastamatiou; Cesar Peñaherrera-Palma; Simon J. Pierce; Francois Poisson; Lina Maria Quintero; Andrew J. Richardson; Paul J. Rogers; Christoph A. Rohner; David R.L. Rowat; Melita Samoilys; Jayson M. Semmens; Marcus Sheaves; George Shillinger; Mahmood Shivji; Sarika Singh; Gregory B. Skomal; Malcolm J. Smale; Laurenne B. Snyders; German Soler; Marc Soria; Kilian M. Stehfest; Simon R. Thorrold; Mariana T. Tolotti; Alison Towner; Paulo Travassos; John P. Tyminski; Frederic Vandeperre; Jeremy J. Vaudo; Yuuki Y. Watanabe; Sam B. Weber; Bradley M. Wetherbee; Timothy D. White; Sean Williams; Patricia M. Zárate; Robert Harcourt; Graeme C. Hays; Mark G. Meekan; Michele Thums; Xabier Irigoien; Victor M. Eguiluz; Carlos M. Duarte; Lara L. Sousa; Samantha J. Simpson; Emily J. Southall; David W. Sims

doi:10.1038/s41586-021-03397-3

Reply to: Shark mortality cannot be assessed by fishery overlap alone

Nuno Queiroz
, Nicolas E. Humphries
, Ana Couto
, Marisa Vedor
, Ivo da Costa
, Ana M.M. Sequeira
, Gonzalo Mucientes
, António M. Santos
, Francisco J. Abascal
, Debra L. Abercrombie
, Katya Abrantes
, David Acuña-Marrero
, André S. Afonso
, Pedro Afonso
, Darrell Anders
, Gonzalo Araujo
, Randall Arauz
, Pascal Bach
, Adam Barnett
, Diego Bernal

Michael L. Berumen, Sandra Bessudo Lion, Natalia P.A. Bezerra, Antonin V. Blaison, Barbara A. Block, Mark E. Bond, Ramon Bonfil, Russell W. Bradford, Camrin D. Braun, Edward J. Brooks, Annabelle Brooks, Judith Brown, Barry D. Bruce, Michael E. Byrne, Steven E. Campana, Aaron B. Carlisle, Demian D. Chapman, Taylor K. Chapple, John Chisholm, Christopher R. Clarke, Eric G. Clua, Jesse E.M. Cochran, Estelle C. Crochelet, Laurent Dagorn, Ryan Daly, Daniel Devia Cortés, Thomas K. Doyle, Michael Drew, Clinton A.J. Duffy, Thor Erikson, Eduardo Espinoza, Luciana C. Ferreira, Francesco Ferretti, John D. Filmalter, G. Chris Fischer, Richard Fitzpatrick, Jorge Fontes, Fabien Forget, Mark Fowler, Malcolm P. Francis, Austin J. Gallagher, Enrico Gennari, Simon D. Goldsworthy, Matthew J. Gollock, Jonathan R. Green, Johan A. Gustafson, Tristan L. Guttridge, Hector M. Guzman, Neil Hammerschlag, Luke Harman, Fábio H.V. Hazin, Matthew Heard, Alex R. Hearn, John C. Holdsworth, Bonnie J. Holmes, Lucy A. Howey, Mauricio Hoyos, Robert E. Hueter, Nigel E. Hussey, Charlie Huveneers, Dylan T. Irion, David M.P. Jacoby, Oliver J.D. Jewell, Ryan Johnson, Lance K.B. Jordan, Warren Joyce, Clare A. Keating Daly, James T. Ketchum, A. Peter Klimley, Alison A. Kock, Pieter Koen, Felipe Ladino, Fernanda O. Lana, James S.E. Lea, Fiona Llewellyn, Warrick S. Lyon, Anna MacDonnell, Bruno C.L. Macena, Heather Marshall, Jaime D. McAllister, Michael A. Meÿer, John J. Morris, Emily R. Nelson, Yannis P. Papastamatiou, Cesar Peñaherrera-Palma, Simon J. Pierce, Francois Poisson, Lina Maria Quintero, Andrew J. Richardson, Paul J. Rogers, Christoph A. Rohner, David R.L. Rowat, Melita Samoilys, Jayson M. Semmens, Marcus Sheaves, George Shillinger, Mahmood Shivji, Sarika Singh, Gregory B. Skomal, Malcolm J. Smale, Laurenne B. Snyders, German Soler, Marc Soria, Kilian M. Stehfest, Simon R. Thorrold, Mariana T. Tolotti, Alison Towner, Paulo Travassos, John P. Tyminski, Frederic Vandeperre, Jeremy J. Vaudo, Yuuki Y. Watanabe, Sam B. Weber, Bradley M. Wetherbee, Timothy D. White, Sean Williams, Patricia M. Zárate, Robert Harcourt, Graeme C. Hays, Mark G. Meekan, Michele Thums, Xabier Irigoien, Victor M. Eguiluz, Carlos M. Duarte, Lara L. Sousa, Samantha J. Simpson, Emily J. Southall, David W. Sims

College of Science and Engineering

Research output: Contribution to journal › Letter › peer-review

11 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Our previously published paper1 provided global fine-scale spatiotemporal estimates (1° × 1°; monthly) of overlap and fishing exposure risk (FEI) between satellite-tracked shark space use and automatic identification system (AIS) longline fishing effort. We did not assess shark mortality directly, but in addition to replying to the Comment by Murua et al.2, we confirm—using regression analysis of spatially matched data—that fishing-induced pelagic shark mortality (catch per unit effort (CPUE)) is greater where FEI is higher.

Original language	English
Pages (from-to)	E8-E16
Journal	Nature
Volume	595
DOIs	https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-021-03397-3
Publication status	Published - 8 Jul 2021

Keywords

spatiotemporal analysis
fishing exposure risk
Satellite tracking
shark space
AIS
conservation biology
marine biology

Access to Document

10.1038/s41586-021-03397-3Licence: In Copyright

Cite this

Queiroz, N., Humphries, N. E., Couto, A., Vedor, M., da Costa, I., Sequeira, A. M. M., Mucientes, G., Santos, A. M., Abascal, F. J., Abercrombie, D. L., Abrantes, K., Acuña-Marrero, D., Afonso, A. S., Afonso, P., Anders, D., Araujo, G., Arauz, R., Bach, P., Barnett, A., ... Sims, D. W. (2021). Reply to: Shark mortality cannot be assessed by fishery overlap alone. Nature, 595, E8-E16. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-021-03397-3

@article{b937e200e5854e29b5f95a8049e873c7,

title = "Reply to: Shark mortality cannot be assessed by fishery overlap alone",

abstract = "Our previously published paper1 provided global fine-scale spatiotemporal estimates (1° × 1°; monthly) of overlap and fishing exposure risk (FEI) between satellite-tracked shark space use and automatic identification system (AIS) longline fishing effort. We did not assess shark mortality directly, but in addition to replying to the Comment by Murua et al.2, we confirm—using regression analysis of spatially matched data—that fishing-induced pelagic shark mortality (catch per unit effort (CPUE)) is greater where FEI is higher.",

keywords = "spatiotemporal analysis, fishing exposure risk, Satellite tracking, shark space, AIS, conservation biology, marine biology",

author = "Nuno Queiroz and Humphries, \{Nicolas E.\} and Ana Couto and Marisa Vedor and \{da Costa\}, Ivo and Sequeira, \{Ana M.M.\} and Gonzalo Mucientes and Santos, \{Ant{\'o}nio M.\} and Abascal, \{Francisco J.\} and Abercrombie, \{Debra L.\} and Katya Abrantes and David Acu{\~n}a-Marrero and Afonso, \{Andr{\'e} S.\} and Pedro Afonso and Darrell Anders and Gonzalo Araujo and Randall Arauz and Pascal Bach and Adam Barnett and Diego Bernal and Berumen, \{Michael L.\} and Lion, \{Sandra Bessudo\} and Bezerra, \{Natalia P.A.\} and Blaison, \{Antonin V.\} and Block, \{Barbara A.\} and Bond, \{Mark E.\} and Ramon Bonfil and Bradford, \{Russell W.\} and Braun, \{Camrin D.\} and Brooks, \{Edward J.\} and Annabelle Brooks and Judith Brown and Bruce, \{Barry D.\} and Byrne, \{Michael E.\} and Campana, \{Steven E.\} and Carlisle, \{Aaron B.\} and Chapman, \{Demian D.\} and Chapple, \{Taylor K.\} and John Chisholm and Clarke, \{Christopher R.\} and Clua, \{Eric G.\} and Cochran, \{Jesse E.M.\} and Crochelet, \{Estelle C.\} and Laurent Dagorn and Ryan Daly and Cort{\'e}s, \{Daniel Devia\} and Doyle, \{Thomas K.\} and Michael Drew and Duffy, \{Clinton A.J.\} and Thor Erikson and Eduardo Espinoza and Ferreira, \{Luciana C.\} and Francesco Ferretti and Filmalter, \{John D.\} and Fischer, \{G. Chris\} and Richard Fitzpatrick and Jorge Fontes and Fabien Forget and Mark Fowler and Francis, \{Malcolm P.\} and Gallagher, \{Austin J.\} and Enrico Gennari and Goldsworthy, \{Simon D.\} and Gollock, \{Matthew J.\} and Green, \{Jonathan R.\} and Gustafson, \{Johan A.\} and Guttridge, \{Tristan L.\} and Guzman, \{Hector M.\} and Neil Hammerschlag and Luke Harman and Hazin, \{F{\'a}bio H.V.\} and Matthew Heard and Hearn, \{Alex R.\} and Holdsworth, \{John C.\} and Holmes, \{Bonnie J.\} and Howey, \{Lucy A.\} and Mauricio Hoyos and Hueter, \{Robert E.\} and Hussey, \{Nigel E.\} and Charlie Huveneers and Irion, \{Dylan T.\} and Jacoby, \{David M.P.\} and Jewell, \{Oliver J.D.\} and Ryan Johnson and Jordan, \{Lance K.B.\} and Warren Joyce and \{Keating Daly\}, \{Clare A.\} and Ketchum, \{James T.\} and Klimley, \{A. Peter\} and Kock, \{Alison A.\} and Pieter Koen and Felipe Ladino and Lana, \{Fernanda O.\} and Lea, \{James S.E.\} and Fiona Llewellyn and Lyon, \{Warrick S.\} and Anna MacDonnell and Macena, \{Bruno C.L.\} and Heather Marshall and McAllister, \{Jaime D.\} and Me{\"y}er, \{Michael A.\} and Morris, \{John J.\} and Nelson, \{Emily R.\} and Papastamatiou, \{Yannis P.\} and Cesar Pe{\~n}aherrera-Palma and Pierce, \{Simon J.\} and Francois Poisson and Quintero, \{Lina Maria\} and Richardson, \{Andrew J.\} and Rogers, \{Paul J.\} and Rohner, \{Christoph A.\} and Rowat, \{David R.L.\} and Melita Samoilys and Semmens, \{Jayson M.\} and Marcus Sheaves and George Shillinger and Mahmood Shivji and Sarika Singh and Skomal, \{Gregory B.\} and Smale, \{Malcolm J.\} and Snyders, \{Laurenne B.\} and German Soler and Marc Soria and Stehfest, \{Kilian M.\} and Thorrold, \{Simon R.\} and Tolotti, \{Mariana T.\} and Alison Towner and Paulo Travassos and Tyminski, \{John P.\} and Frederic Vandeperre and Vaudo, \{Jeremy J.\} and Watanabe, \{Yuuki Y.\} and Weber, \{Sam B.\} and Wetherbee, \{Bradley M.\} and White, \{Timothy D.\} and Sean Williams and Z{\'a}rate, \{Patricia M.\} and Robert Harcourt and Hays, \{Graeme C.\} and Meekan, \{Mark G.\} and Michele Thums and Xabier Irigoien and Eguiluz, \{Victor M.\} and Duarte, \{Carlos M.\} and Sousa, \{Lara L.\} and Simpson, \{Samantha J.\} and Southall, \{Emily J.\} and Sims, \{David W.\}",

year = "2021",

month = jul,

day = "8",

doi = "10.1038/s41586-021-03397-3",

language = "English",

volume = "595",

pages = "E8--E16",

journal = "Nature",

issn = "0028-0836",

publisher = "Nature Research",

}

Queiroz, N, Humphries, NE, Couto, A, Vedor, M, da Costa, I, Sequeira, AMM, Mucientes, G, Santos, AM, Abascal, FJ, Abercrombie, DL, Abrantes, K, Acuña-Marrero, D, Afonso, AS, Afonso, P, Anders, D, Araujo, G, Arauz, R, Bach, P, Barnett, A, Bernal, D, Berumen, ML, Lion, SB, Bezerra, NPA, Blaison, AV, Block, BA, Bond, ME, Bonfil, R, Bradford, RW, Braun, CD, Brooks, EJ, Brooks, A, Brown, J, Bruce, BD, Byrne, ME, Campana, SE, Carlisle, AB, Chapman, DD, Chapple, TK, Chisholm, J, Clarke, CR, Clua, EG, Cochran, JEM, Crochelet, EC, Dagorn, L, Daly, R, Cortés, DD, Doyle, TK, Drew, M, Duffy, CAJ, Erikson, T, Espinoza, E, Ferreira, LC, Ferretti, F, Filmalter, JD, Fischer, GC, Fitzpatrick, R, Fontes, J, Forget, F, Fowler, M, Francis, MP, Gallagher, AJ, Gennari, E, Goldsworthy, SD, Gollock, MJ, Green, JR, Gustafson, JA, Guttridge, TL, Guzman, HM, Hammerschlag, N, Harman, L, Hazin, FHV, Heard, M, Hearn, AR, Holdsworth, JC, Holmes, BJ, Howey, LA, Hoyos, M, Hueter, RE, Hussey, NE, Huveneers, C, Irion, DT, Jacoby, DMP, Jewell, OJD, Johnson, R, Jordan, LKB, Joyce, W, Keating Daly, CA, Ketchum, JT, Klimley, AP, Kock, AA, Koen, P, Ladino, F, Lana, FO, Lea, JSE, Llewellyn, F, Lyon, WS, MacDonnell, A, Macena, BCL, Marshall, H, McAllister, JD, Meÿer, MA, Morris, JJ, Nelson, ER, Papastamatiou, YP, Peñaherrera-Palma, C, Pierce, SJ, Poisson, F, Quintero, LM, Richardson, AJ, Rogers, PJ, Rohner, CA, Rowat, DRL, Samoilys, M, Semmens, JM, Sheaves, M, Shillinger, G, Shivji, M, Singh, S, Skomal, GB, Smale, MJ, Snyders, LB, Soler, G, Soria, M, Stehfest, KM, Thorrold, SR, Tolotti, MT, Towner, A, Travassos, P, Tyminski, JP, Vandeperre, F, Vaudo, JJ, Watanabe, YY, Weber, SB, Wetherbee, BM, White, TD, Williams, S, Zárate, PM, Harcourt, R, Hays, GC, Meekan, MG, Thums, M, Irigoien, X, Eguiluz, VM, Duarte, CM, Sousa, LL, Simpson, SJ, Southall, EJ & Sims, DW 2021, 'Reply to: Shark mortality cannot be assessed by fishery overlap alone', Nature, vol. 595, pp. E8-E16. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-021-03397-3

TY - JOUR

T1 - Reply to

T2 - Shark mortality cannot be assessed by fishery overlap alone

AU - Queiroz, Nuno

AU - Humphries, Nicolas E.

AU - Couto, Ana

AU - Vedor, Marisa

AU - da Costa, Ivo

AU - Sequeira, Ana M.M.

AU - Mucientes, Gonzalo

AU - Santos, António M.

AU - Abascal, Francisco J.

AU - Abercrombie, Debra L.

AU - Abrantes, Katya

AU - Acuña-Marrero, David

AU - Afonso, André S.

AU - Afonso, Pedro

AU - Anders, Darrell

AU - Araujo, Gonzalo

AU - Arauz, Randall

AU - Bach, Pascal

AU - Barnett, Adam

AU - Bernal, Diego

AU - Berumen, Michael L.

AU - Lion, Sandra Bessudo

AU - Bezerra, Natalia P.A.

AU - Blaison, Antonin V.

AU - Block, Barbara A.

AU - Bond, Mark E.

AU - Bonfil, Ramon

AU - Bradford, Russell W.

AU - Braun, Camrin D.

AU - Brooks, Edward J.

AU - Brooks, Annabelle

AU - Brown, Judith

AU - Bruce, Barry D.

AU - Byrne, Michael E.

AU - Campana, Steven E.

AU - Carlisle, Aaron B.

AU - Chapman, Demian D.

AU - Chapple, Taylor K.

AU - Chisholm, John

AU - Clarke, Christopher R.

AU - Clua, Eric G.

AU - Cochran, Jesse E.M.

AU - Crochelet, Estelle C.

AU - Dagorn, Laurent

AU - Daly, Ryan

AU - Cortés, Daniel Devia

AU - Doyle, Thomas K.

AU - Drew, Michael

AU - Duffy, Clinton A.J.

AU - Erikson, Thor

AU - Espinoza, Eduardo

AU - Ferreira, Luciana C.

AU - Ferretti, Francesco

AU - Filmalter, John D.

AU - Fischer, G. Chris

AU - Fitzpatrick, Richard

AU - Fontes, Jorge

AU - Forget, Fabien

AU - Fowler, Mark

AU - Francis, Malcolm P.

AU - Gallagher, Austin J.

AU - Gennari, Enrico

AU - Goldsworthy, Simon D.

AU - Gollock, Matthew J.

AU - Green, Jonathan R.

AU - Gustafson, Johan A.

AU - Guttridge, Tristan L.

AU - Guzman, Hector M.

AU - Hammerschlag, Neil

AU - Harman, Luke

AU - Hazin, Fábio H.V.

AU - Heard, Matthew

AU - Hearn, Alex R.

AU - Holdsworth, John C.

AU - Holmes, Bonnie J.

AU - Howey, Lucy A.

AU - Hoyos, Mauricio

AU - Hueter, Robert E.

AU - Hussey, Nigel E.

AU - Huveneers, Charlie

AU - Irion, Dylan T.

AU - Jacoby, David M.P.

AU - Jewell, Oliver J.D.

AU - Johnson, Ryan

AU - Jordan, Lance K.B.

AU - Joyce, Warren

AU - Keating Daly, Clare A.

AU - Ketchum, James T.

AU - Klimley, A. Peter

AU - Kock, Alison A.

AU - Koen, Pieter

AU - Ladino, Felipe

AU - Lana, Fernanda O.

AU - Lea, James S.E.

AU - Llewellyn, Fiona

AU - Lyon, Warrick S.

AU - MacDonnell, Anna

AU - Macena, Bruno C.L.

AU - Marshall, Heather

AU - McAllister, Jaime D.

AU - Meÿer, Michael A.

AU - Morris, John J.

AU - Nelson, Emily R.

AU - Papastamatiou, Yannis P.

AU - Peñaherrera-Palma, Cesar

AU - Pierce, Simon J.

AU - Poisson, Francois

AU - Quintero, Lina Maria

AU - Richardson, Andrew J.

AU - Rogers, Paul J.

AU - Rohner, Christoph A.

AU - Rowat, David R.L.

AU - Samoilys, Melita

AU - Semmens, Jayson M.

AU - Sheaves, Marcus

AU - Shillinger, George

AU - Shivji, Mahmood

AU - Singh, Sarika

AU - Skomal, Gregory B.

AU - Smale, Malcolm J.

AU - Snyders, Laurenne B.

AU - Soler, German

AU - Soria, Marc

AU - Stehfest, Kilian M.

AU - Thorrold, Simon R.

AU - Tolotti, Mariana T.

AU - Towner, Alison

AU - Travassos, Paulo

AU - Tyminski, John P.

AU - Vandeperre, Frederic

AU - Vaudo, Jeremy J.

AU - Watanabe, Yuuki Y.

AU - Weber, Sam B.

AU - Wetherbee, Bradley M.

AU - White, Timothy D.

AU - Williams, Sean

AU - Zárate, Patricia M.

AU - Harcourt, Robert

AU - Hays, Graeme C.

AU - Meekan, Mark G.

AU - Thums, Michele

AU - Irigoien, Xabier

AU - Eguiluz, Victor M.

AU - Duarte, Carlos M.

AU - Sousa, Lara L.

AU - Simpson, Samantha J.

AU - Southall, Emily J.

AU - Sims, David W.

PY - 2021/7/8

Y1 - 2021/7/8

N2 - Our previously published paper1 provided global fine-scale spatiotemporal estimates (1° × 1°; monthly) of overlap and fishing exposure risk (FEI) between satellite-tracked shark space use and automatic identification system (AIS) longline fishing effort. We did not assess shark mortality directly, but in addition to replying to the Comment by Murua et al.2, we confirm—using regression analysis of spatially matched data—that fishing-induced pelagic shark mortality (catch per unit effort (CPUE)) is greater where FEI is higher.

AB - Our previously published paper1 provided global fine-scale spatiotemporal estimates (1° × 1°; monthly) of overlap and fishing exposure risk (FEI) between satellite-tracked shark space use and automatic identification system (AIS) longline fishing effort. We did not assess shark mortality directly, but in addition to replying to the Comment by Murua et al.2, we confirm—using regression analysis of spatially matched data—that fishing-induced pelagic shark mortality (catch per unit effort (CPUE)) is greater where FEI is higher.

KW - spatiotemporal analysis

KW - fishing exposure risk

KW - Satellite tracking

KW - shark space

KW - AIS

KW - conservation biology

KW - marine biology

UR - https://www.scopus.com/pages/publications/85109722098

UR - http://purl.org/au-research/grants/ARC/DP210103091

U2 - 10.1038/s41586-021-03397-3

DO - 10.1038/s41586-021-03397-3

M3 - Letter

AN - SCOPUS:85109722098

SN - 0028-0836

VL - 595

SP - E8-E16

JO - Nature

JF - Nature

ER -

Reply to: Shark mortality cannot be assessed by fishery overlap alone

Abstract

Keywords

Access to Document

Other files and links

Fingerprint

Cite this